Privacy and Confidentiality
Privacy and confidentiality — the circle, the exceptions, the family, the record, and four cases
Opening

Privacy and Confidentiality
Chapter 6 of the course guide asks one question: what do we owe patients about what they tell us? Confidentiality is one of the oldest duties in medicine, and it is also the one students breach most easily, usually without noticing, on a phone.
The lecture has four parts: the circle and where the duty comes from; what it demands in practice and when it yields; the family, the digital record and Saudi law; and four cases from Chapter 6, with the Tarasoff case as a closing remark.

Learning objectives
By the end you should be able to define privacy and confidentiality and tell them apart; trace their historical, ethical and Islamic foundations; say what confidentiality demands on the ward, in clinic and online; recognize the legitimate exceptions and apply them; handle a family's request to withhold information; apply all of this to electronic records, messaging and social media; and describe the Saudi framework that stands behind it.
The circle

1 · The circle
Part one: the circle of confidence, three definitions that are not synonyms, and the foundations of the duty in three traditions.

The circle of confidence
A patient tells a stranger in a white coat things they may hide from their own family. They do so because of what the role promises, not because they know you.
Confidentiality is therefore not paperwork. It is the condition that makes the clinical relationship possible. Information moves to the care team when care needs it, and never to everyone else.

Privacy, confidentiality, secrecy
Privacy is the patient's right to control access to themselves and their information. It has a bodily side, during examination, and an informational side, over who knows about their health.
Confidentiality is the clinician's duty to use what is disclosed only for its intended purpose and to share it only with consent. It is relational, and it is not optional. Secrecy is simply keeping something hidden; confidentiality is more than that, because it is owed to a particular person.

An old duty, in three traditions
The Hippocratic Oath binds the physician to keep secret what is learned in treatment. The World Medical Association (WMA) International Code of Medical Ethics allows disclosure only with consent, or when a real and imminent threat can be removed only by a breach. Islamic ethics forbids spying, praises concealing the faults of others, and treats what a patient discloses as an amanah, a trust.
Beneath all three lie three values: autonomy, because the patient decides who knows; dignity, because some things are shameful to have exposed; and trust, because without it patients stop telling the truth.

The Islamic foundation
The Quran forbids spying (Al-Hujurat 49:12), and the hadith in Sahih Muslim promises that whoever conceals a Muslim, Allah will conceal him on the Day of Resurrection.
Two terms from the chapter belong here. Amanah (أمانة) is trustworthiness: what a patient discloses is a trust placed in the physician. Ghaybah (غيبة), backbiting, covers the casual talk about patients discussed on the next slide.
In practice

2 · In practice
Part two: where breaches actually happen, the three narrow exceptions, and the three tests for protecting a third party.

Where breaches actually happen
On the ward: draw the curtains, lower your voice, use a private room when you can. Consent to admission is not consent to be a teaching case, so ask first.
In the record: open only the records of patients in your care. Looking up a file out of curiosity is a serious breach even if you tell no one, and electronic systems log every access. Outside the room: a case told with identifying detail in a corridor, a lift or at dinner is a breach wherever it is told. Saudi practitioners must keep records confidential and use them only for care, under the Executive Regulations of the Health Professions Practice Law.

When confidentiality may yield
There are three exceptions, and each is narrow. Consent must be explicit, documented and limited to named information for named recipients.
A third party may be protected when there is a serious, credible and imminent threat to an identifiable person; the tests are on the next slide. And the law may require disclosure: notifiable diseases such as tuberculosis, meningococcal disease and cholera are reported to public health regardless of consent, and a court may compel disclosure. In each case, disclose to the right body and no further.

The duty to protect: three tests
Breaking confidence to protect someone else is justified only when all three tests hold. The threat must be serious, credible and imminent, to an identifiable person. Disclosure must be necessary, with no less invasive step that would remove the risk. And it must be proportionate: the minimum, told to the right person, for this risk only.
Whenever you disclose, document why each test was met.
The family, the record, and the law

3 · The family, the record, the law
Part three: the family's request to withhold a diagnosis, confidentiality on screens and in messaging apps, and the Saudi framework.

The right belongs to the patient
Family involvement is central in Arab and Muslim households, and it is welcome when the patient wants it. But the right to confidentiality belongs to the patient, not the family.
A request to withhold a serious diagnosis overrides the patient's autonomy, rests on a premise that is usually false (most patients want to know), damages trust when the truth emerges, and blocks the patient's own decisions. The way through: meet the family first and acknowledge their fear; ask the patient, privately, how much they want to know; and disclose at the patient's pace.

Confidentiality on screens
For Electronic Health Records (EHRs): open only your own patients' records, use authorized and secure systems, log out when you step away, report a breach at once, and never photograph or screenshot a record.
For messaging: consumer apps such as WhatsApp leak through personal phones, group chats and forwarding. Use approved, encrypted, institution-run platforms. If there is truly no alternative, anonymize as far as possible, and remember that an identifying image needs explicit consent. Once forwarded, an image cannot be recalled.

The Saudi framework
In the Kingdom confidentiality is a legal and professional obligation, not only an ethical ideal. The Executive Regulations of the Health Professions Practice Law (Royal Decree M/59, 1426 H) require records to be kept confidential and used only for care. The Saudi Commission for Health Specialties (SCFHS) Code of Ethics for Healthcare Practitioners sets out the professional duty and its limits. The Ministry of Health (MOH) Patient Bill of Rights and Responsibilities makes privacy and confidentiality patient rights, and the MOH notifiable disease regulations require listed diseases to be reported regardless of consent.
Four cases

Four cases
Work each of the four cases from Chapter 6 through five questions: the four topics of Jonsen, Siegler and Winslade (medical indications, patient preferences, quality of life and contextual features) and the guide's added question on what the sharia and its aims (maqasid) require.

Case 6.1: The WhatsApp ward round
A junior doctor posts an identifiable chest X-ray to a department group of twelve. Ask: what are the ethical issues, and what should happen next?
Points to reach: identifiable data was shared without consent, on an unapproved platform, to people who can forward it. A teaching motive does not cure the breach, and the harm includes the patient's lost trust. Next: delete the image and ask every member to delete it, apologize to the patient honestly, report through the hospital's incident system, and next time anonymize, ask, and use an approved platform.

Case 6.2: The concerned employer
A bus driver with newly diagnosed epilepsy keeps driving because he cannot afford to lose his job, and his employer calls to ask why he has been absent.
Points to reach: the employer is owed nothing about the diagnosis without the patient's consent. The patient is owed real help: take his fear for his livelihood seriously, explain the risk, explore sick leave or a non-driving role, document the advice, and tell him honestly that you may have to act. The public: if he keeps driving passengers, the three tests can be met. Identify which authority should be told, and tell only that authority.

Case 6.3: The spouse's request
A woman found to have a sexually transmitted infection (STI) has not mentioned her husband, who asks the nurse in the waiting room what the problem is.
Points to reach: the nurse neither discloses nor confirms anything, politely; being her husband gives him no right to her information. In her care: a private conversation about treatment, the risk to her partner and his need for testing and treatment, with help to tell him or assisted partner notification. Concealment (sitr) and her privacy weigh against preventing harm to him; if she refuses, the third-party tests apply, and the decision belongs to senior staff and hospital policy.

Case 6.4: The family veto
The family of a man with advanced colon cancer asks you not to tell him, but when you are alone he asks you directly what was found.
Points to reach: his question is his answer to how much he wants to know. Do not lie. Ask what he suspects and how much he wants to hear now, tell him gently and at his pace with a plan, and offer to have family present. Then explain to the family why you could not deceive him. The principles: autonomy and his right to information, non-maleficence (the harm of deception against a feared shock that is usually overstated), beneficence, and truthfulness as amanah.
To close

Key terms
Privacy, confidentiality, secrecy, notifiable disease, Tarasoff duty, family collusion, amanah, ghaybah and anonymization. Match each one to a moment in the cases: family collusion in Case 6.4, anonymization in Case 6.1, the Tarasoff duty in Case 6.2, and ghaybah in corridor talk.

Five things to take out of the room
Confidentiality is the condition of care, not a courtesy. Privacy is the patient's right; confidentiality is your duty. The exceptions are narrow: consent, a serious threat to an identifiable person, or the law. The right belongs to the patient, not the family. And a screenshot is a disclosure: anonymize, ask, and use approved platforms.

Further reading
Chapter 6 of the course guide; Moskop and colleagues (2005) on privacy and confidentiality in emergency medicine; Lee and Wu (2002) on disclosing a cancer diagnosis when the family says no; the SCFHS Code of Ethics for Healthcare Practitioners (2014); the MOH Patient Bill of Rights and Responsibilities and the Executive Regulations of the Health Professions Practice Law; and Beauchamp and Childress, Principles of Biomedical Ethics, 8th edition, Chapter 8.

Closing remark: a threat told in confidence
A young man told his university psychologist that he intended to kill a woman who had rejected him. Apart from a brief, failed attempt to have him detained, no one warned her, and about two months later he killed her. Her parents sued, and in 1976 the California Supreme Court held that the protective privilege ends where the public peril begins.
Run the three tests: the threat was serious, credible and imminent, and she was identifiable; a warning was necessary once detention had failed; and a warning would have been proportionate. Confidentiality is strong, the condition of all care, but it is not absolute, and the line is drawn at serious danger to an identifiable person.
Before next time
This lecture was Chapter 6 — Privacy and Confidentiality. Work the four cases at the end of Chapter 6 and bring your answers. The second lecture of this week is patients with special needs, Chapter 12. Week 14, after the autumn break, is surgery, women and children, and the end of life: Chapters 9, 8 and 10.
The question bank has 113 scenarios with the answers explained, and the Trainee Edition is the shorter version written for the wards.